Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven
What LiveWire costs the parent, and what the plan leaves out. Ground Truth No. 02, the LinkedIn series in full: four parts, 37 slides. The full brief, with every figure linked to its filing, is here.
Contact Patch Advisory · William Weppner · September 2026
Part 1 · The Arithmetic · 10 slides
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · Part 1 of 4
BACK TO THE BRICKS. DOWN TO BREAKEVEN.
What LiveWire costs Harley-Davidson, what the new plan leaves out, and what 2027 looks like on the company's own numbers.
2026 guidance, added up
Part 1 · The arithmetic
Harley-Davidson, Inc. · HOGSeptember 2026
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · The route
The arithmetic
Juneau Avenue, Milwaukee
Juneau Avenue, reopened for return-to-office in March 2026. Every decision in this brief was signed here.
Part I
The arithmetic
Add up the guidance: about zero. The subsidiary's loss exceeds the motor company's profit.
Part II
The sale
2025's profit was the finance company, sold. $180M a year traded for $1.25B once.
Part III
The subsidiary
$422M consolidated. A third of the profit drag from 0.6% of revenue. Cash to May 2027.
Part IV
The plan
Five pillars, six targets. The 2027 number is a 5% margin, below 2019.
Part V
The bet
$1.6B of buybacks, and one motorcycle carrying the growth target: the 883.
Part VI
The final word
LiveWire didn't break Harley. It is what the new Harley can't afford.
Contact Patch · Ground Truth No. 02contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
01 / 09
5 May 2026, the call
The call that replaced the five-year strategy. Fourteen words on LiveWire.
What they said · 5 May 2026 · introducing the plan
Harley-Davidson's new CEO, on the call that replaced the old five-year strategy:
"Over the last several years, we leaned heavily into Touring and Electric."
Fourteen words. The parent company's verdict on Hardwire, on LiveWire, and on five years of product decisions.
H1 2026 consolidated operating income was $99.5M, so the full-year guide implies a second-half loss. Q4 is seasonally weak (HDMC lost $260M in Q4 2025), and management has beaten its own ranges twice this year. The guidance may be conservative.
The sum is checked. Segments add to the consolidated line in 2025 and 2024 to the decimal. No corporate eliminations sit between them.
It is still the number they chose to publish.
Consolidated operating income, $ millions · Q4 2025 alone lost $260M at HDMC
Part 2: where the 2025 profit actually came from, and why it does not happen twice.
Full brief: 16 sections in six parts, every figure linked to its filing, open items and corrections published. contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
Former H-D product manager · Independent analystNo position held
Part 2 · The Sale · 8 slides
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · Part 2 of 4
$180M A YEAR, TRADED FOR $1.25B ONCE.
In 2025 the motor company lost money and the subsidiary lost more. The year was profitable because the finance company sold its loan book.
HDFS operating income, $ millions: the cliff after the sale
Part 2 · The sale
Harley-Davidson, Inc. · HOGSeptember 2026
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · The route
The sale
The finance desk
The finance desk. Two-thirds of the loans written here for the next five years are already sold.
Part I
The arithmetic
Add up the guidance: about zero. The subsidiary's loss exceeds the motor company's profit.
Part II
The sale
2025's profit was the finance company, sold. $180M a year traded for $1.25B once.
Part III
The subsidiary
$422M consolidated. A third of the profit drag from 0.6% of revenue. Cash to May 2027.
Part IV
The plan
Five pillars, six targets. The 2027 number is a 5% margin, below 2019.
Part V
The bet
$1.6B of buybacks, and one motorcycle carrying the growth target: the 883.
Part VI
The final word
LiveWire didn't break Harley. It is what the new Harley can't afford.
Contact Patch · Ground Truth No. 02contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
01 / 07
2025 operating income by segment · $ millions
Two segments lost money. The third was sold.
HDFS: "record-high earnings, driven by the HDFS transaction." The motorcycle company and its subsidiary lost $103.7M together; the finance company covered it four times over, once.
Seven years of HDFS earnings, paid up front. Not a bad trade if the cash earns more than HDFS did. So far: a $200M buyback at ~$26.50, and $1.9B sitting on a balance sheet guided to breakeven.
$ millions · the two sides of the trade, at the 2024 run rate
This is why 2025 EPS was $2.78 and not something near zero.
And why the 2026 guidance looks like a cliff. It is not a cliff. It is the ground. The $350M HDMC EBITDA target now has to carry the enterprise in a way it never had to before the sale.
2025 operating income by segment, $ millions · 10-K FY2025
Ground Truth No. 02 · Part 2Contact Patch Advisory
07 / 07
Part 3: what LiveWire costs the parent, and the date it stops being a line item and becomes a decision.
Full brief: 16 sections in six parts, every figure linked to its filing, open items and corrections published. contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
Former H-D product manager · Independent analystNo position held
Part 3 · The Subsidiary · 9 slides
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · Part 3 of 4
GUIDED TO LOSE MORE THAN THE MOTOR COMPANY MAKES.
$422 million of LiveWire losses consolidated into Harley-Davidson since 2022. Cash to May 2027. A note due in December.
LiveWire's share of the drag on consolidated operating income
Part 3 · The subsidiary
Harley-Davidson, Inc. · HOGSeptember 2026
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · The route
The subsidiary
One electric on a Harley floor
One electric on a Harley floor. The dealer did not ask for it and does not get paid much to sell it.
Part I
The arithmetic
Add up the guidance: about zero. The subsidiary's loss exceeds the motor company's profit.
Part II
The sale
2025's profit was the finance company, sold. $180M a year traded for $1.25B once.
Part III
The subsidiary
$422M consolidated. A third of the profit drag from 0.6% of revenue. Cash to May 2027.
Part IV
The plan
Five pillars, six targets. The 2027 number is a 5% margin, below 2019.
Part V
The bet
$1.6B of buybacks, and one motorcycle carrying the growth target: the 883.
Part VI
The final word
LiveWire didn't break Harley. It is what the new Harley can't afford.
Contact Patch · Ground Truth No. 02contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
01 / 08
LiveWire operating loss as a share of H-D consolidated operating income
0.6% of revenue. A third of the drag.
Every dollar LiveWire loses lands in Harley-Davidson's operating income. Only the ~11% belonging to the public minority comes back out, below the line. H-D shareholders bear ~89%.
February 2024, a convertible loan. November 2025, a secured one. Same counterparty, different seat.
The seat change · one instrument, rewritten
February 2024
A $100M convertible loan. If LiveWire could not repay, Harley-Davidson would take equity. A parent's instrument. Never drawn.
November 2025
Amended and restated at $75M. Conversion feature removed. Security interest over substantially all assets added. SOFR + 4%, compounding, all due 15 December 2027. First $10M of any equity raised goes to the lender. Drawn in full 15 December 2025.
A convertible says: if this fails, we own it. A secured loan says: if this fails, we get paid first.
Because LiveWire is already consolidated, no ownership change short of deconsolidation improves Harley-Davidson's reported operating income.
Buying the minority for $28M would be the cheapest corporate action in the company's recent history. It would change the operating line by exactly nothing. Back to the Bricks handles this by scoring HDMC alone.
Already consolidated · the whole loss is on the line either way; $28M moves nothing above minority interest
Calculated · Ground Truth No. 02 §07Contact Patch Advisory
07 / 08
What the parent has said in 2026
"LiveWire is now working diligently to attract its own sources of capital to continue to finance its operations and future plans."
Artie Starrs · Q4 2025 call · 10 Feb 2026
No 2026 statement from Starrs or CFO Root uses "strategic alternatives," "divestiture" or "wind-down." Back to the Bricks does not mention LiveWire outside its forward-looking factors. LiveWire's 10-Q says it will pursue financing "during the third quarter of 2026." That quarter ends in three weeks.
Source: Q4 2025 call · Back to the Bricks release · LVWR 10-QContact Patch Advisory
08 / 08
Part 4: what Back to the Bricks actually commits to, what Hardwire delivered, and the one motorcycle carrying the growth target.
Full brief: 16 sections in six parts, every figure linked to its filing, open items and corrections published. contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
Former H-D product manager · Independent analystNo position held
Part 4 · The Bricks · 10 slides
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · Part 4 of 4
FIVE PILLARS. SIX TARGETS. NO ELECTRIC.
Five pillars, six targets, one dated number, and a 2027 that lands everything at once: the EBITDA target, the Sportster, and the LiveWire note.
Consolidated operating income, actual and on the plan, $ millions
Part 4 · The bricks
Harley-Davidson, Inc. · HOGSeptember 2026
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · The route
The plan, the bet, the final word
Back to the Bricks, 5 May 2026
5 May 2026. Five pillars, six targets, no subsidiary.
Part I
The arithmetic
Add up the guidance: about zero. The subsidiary's loss exceeds the motor company's profit.
Part II
The sale
2025's profit was the finance company, sold. $180M a year traded for $1.25B once.
Part III
The subsidiary
$422M consolidated. A third of the profit drag from 0.6% of revenue. Cash to May 2027.
Part IV
The plan
Five pillars, six targets. The 2027 number is a 5% margin, below 2019.
Part V
The bet
$1.6B of buybacks, and one motorcycle carrying the growth target: the 883.
Part VI
The final word
LiveWire didn't break Harley. It is what the new Harley can't afford.
Contact Patch · Ground Truth No. 02contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
01 / 09
Back to the Bricks · 5 May 2026 · the five pillars, as written
1Deep appreciation of competitive advantages and legacy"iconic brand, diversified and powerful revenue channels, and best-in-class dealer network"
2Renewed commitment to the exclusive dealer network"enable dealers to double profitability in 2026 and then double it again by 2029"
3Recapture share where H-D has "right to win""new motorcycles, used motorcycles, Parts & Accessories, and Apparel & Licensing"
4Strong financial position"a path to stronger free cash flow and EBITDA margin over time"
5Bolstered management team"a number of leadership appointments"
The word "electric" does not appear. LiveWire is in the forward-looking factors only.
The word “electric” does not appear · LiveWire is in the forward-looking factors only
Source: Back to the Bricks release · 5 May 2026Contact Patch Advisory
Hardwire promised 15% op margin by 2025. Got (0.8%).
Fixed cost
−$150M by 2027
“Not including LiveWire.”
Not in it: a revenue figure, EPS, free cash flow, Sportster volume, a capital-return commitment, or any LiveWire target.
Source: Back to the Bricks release · Q1, Q2 2026 calls · 10-K FY2025Contact Patch Advisory
03 / 09
The only dated number, translated
$350M
HDMC EBITDA · 2027
≈ 5%
OPERATING MARGIN · DERIVED (D&A ~$170M/YR FROM Q2 2026 ADJ. EBITDA LESS OPERATING INCOME)
HDMC ran a 6.3% margin in 2019, the year Hardwire was written to fix. The new plan's target is below where the company stood before the old plan.
HDMC operating margin · the new target sits below the year the old plan set out to fix
Calculated · confirm HDMC D&A from the 10-K (open item 2)Contact Patch Advisory
04 / 09
Hardwire, promised vs delivered
Hardwire promised 15% by 2025 and delivered 0.8%. The banners are still up.
Hardwire, 2021–2025 · promised vs delivered
Commitment
Target
FY2025
HDMC revenue
+5–7% CAGR → ~$5.5–5.9B
$3,578M · −21% vs 2021
HDMC op margin
15% by 2025
(0.8%)
EPS
Low-double-digit growth
$4.19 → $2.78
HDFS
Double-digit growth
$490M via a one-time sale
Cost
$400M productivity
New plan needs $150M more
Lead in Electric
100,000 LiveWires/yr from 2026
923. $422M of losses.
Every quantified target missed. Shareholders withheld over 48% from the CEO in May 2025; he and two directors were gone within a year.
Source: Hardwire release 2 Feb 2021 · Stage II 10 May 2022 · 10-K FY2025Contact Patch Advisory
05 / 09
Capital returned
$1.63 billion of buybacks at an average of $31, for a stock at $28.
Capital returned · average repurchase price by year vs the share price, 4 Sep 2026
$1.63 billion of buybacks. 52.1M shares. $31.30 average.
Those shares are worth about $1.47B at $28.30. HOG was $30.47 the day Zeitz took the job in February 2020. Market cap today: ~$2.9B, with $1.9B of cash on the balance sheet.
The 883. Discontinued in 2022 because it did not make money; back in 2027 as the plan's one volume lever.
The bet · what the growth target needs vs what the Sportster used to sell · units a year
One motorcycle carries the growth target.
Starrs: the Sportster market "as recently as five, six years ago… was 35,000–40,000+ on a global basis." Recover a third of that and the 883 alone delivers two years of the plan's growth.
Raymond James, same call: "there's a reason why Sportster was discontinued, right? It was hard to make money." Starrs: the cost is now "extremely comfortable against the expected MSRP."
York, 2027, if every target lands: 143,000 motorcycles, two-thirds of 2019.
2027, if every target lands on time
Plan delivered
Worldwide retail
~143,000 · 66% of 2019
HDMC operating income
~$190M · ~5% margin
HDFS operating income
~$80–100M · a third of 2024
LiveWire
Unaddressed · cash out mid-2027 · $85M due December
Consolidated operating income
~$210M with LiveWire · ~$280M without
Dealers
~1,150, twice as profitable as 2025
A quarter of 2023's earnings. Two-thirds of 2019's motorcycles. Three-quarters of the dealers. That is the plan, working.
Calculated from the company's own targets · Ground Truth No. 02 §12Contact Patch Advisory
08 / 09
Three things that are true at once
LiveWire did not break Harley-Davidson. A $75M loss does not take a company from $779M to zero. Touring, tariffs, a 12% retail decline and the HDFS sale did that. The electric bet is the flattering villain.
LiveWire is exactly what the new Harley cannot afford. When the motor company is guided to make $10–50M, a $70–80M loss is the difference between a profit and a loss. The plan solves this by not counting it.
The decision has a date. Cash to May 2027. Note due December 2027. EBITDA target: 2027. Nobody has said what the decision is.
The decision has a date. Three of them.
Ground Truth No. 02 · §13 · Analysis, not reportingContact Patch Advisory
09 / 09
Which brick is LiveWire under?
Back to the Bricks has five pillars, six targets and a two-year clock. It is scored on the motor company. Harley-Davidson, Inc. is not the motor company. It is HDMC, plus a finance company sold forward, minus a subsidiary guided to lose more than HDMC makes, with a note due in the plan's own target year.
Full brief: 16 sections in six parts, every source linked, open items and corrections published. contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02
Scored on the motor company · the subsidiary sits under the footing
Former H-D product manager · Independent analystNo position held
Ground Truth No. 02
Harley-Davidson: Back to the Bricks, Down to Breakeven · The route
Six parts, one thesis
The bricks
The bricks. The plan is named after the building.
Part I
The arithmetic
Add up the guidance: about zero. The subsidiary's loss exceeds the motor company's profit.
Part II
The sale
2025's profit was the finance company, sold. $180M a year traded for $1.25B once.
Part III
The subsidiary
$422M consolidated. A third of the profit drag from 0.6% of revenue. Cash to May 2027.
Part IV
The plan
Five pillars, six targets. The 2027 number is a 5% margin, below 2019.
Part V
The bet
$1.6B of buybacks, and one motorcycle carrying the growth target: the 883.
Part VI
The final word
LiveWire didn't break Harley. It is what the new Harley can't afford.
Contact Patch · Ground Truth No. 02contactpatchadvisory.com/groundtruth/02